One Year in an Alfa Romeo Tonale 160 ch After 20 Years of Loyalty to Volkswagen: ‘I Fell Head Over Heels in Love’

85.8 / 100

Overall Rating - View the details of the ratings

After 20 years behind the wheel of a Volkswagen Golf, Markus, a German driver, completely changed his lifestyle by choosing a Alfa Romeo Tonale Hybrid 160 ch Intensa. Ten months and 10,000 kilometers later, he shares his experience with the Italpassion community. Between his love for its looks, the joy of driving it, and a few flaws, here’s his take on it.

Advertising

There are cars you choose after comparing dozens of spec sheets. And then there are those that make it love at first sight. For 20 years, Markus remained loyal to Volkswagen, driving the Golf 5, 6, and 7 station wagons in succession. It was a long-standing habit he finally broke in favor of an Italian SUV. «I fell head over heels in love with the Tonale’s design at first sight. And I still am today,» he says.

He chose a Alfa Romeo Tonale 1.5 Hybrid with 160 ch in the Intensa trim level, which hit the market in November 2025. After owning it for ten months and driving 10,000 kilometers—mostly in the city—Markus now has enough perspective to take stock of his experience so far. And judging by his notes, he has few regrets about switching brands.

Advertising

Markus's Tonale at a Glance

FeatureData
ModelAlfa Romeo Tonale
Motorization1.5 Hybrid 160 ch
FinishIntensa
Placing into circulationNovember 2025
Time of possession10 months
Odometer reading11,000 km
Distance traveled10,000 km
Primary UseUrban Trips
Vintage CarsVolkswagen Golf 5, 6, and 7 station wagons

A 160 ch engine is sufficient, but the hybrid system could be improved

With its 160 ch 1.5 Hybrid engine, Markus’s Tonale isn’t meant to be a hardcore sports car. But for everyday use—primarily in the city—the available power meets his expectations. «For the average driver, it’s more than enough,» he sums up.

The German driver also appreciates the engine’s overall smoothness, which makes driving a pleasure. He particularly highlights the SUV’s character when he selects Dynamic mode. «In Dynamic mode, I was pleasantly surprised.»

However, not everything is perfect. Markus points out a flaw in the hybrid powertrain’s management, specifically during the transition from electric to internal combustion engine power. «When switching to the internal combustion engine, there’s always a jolt,» he explains. This occurs frequently enough to warrant mention in his review. On the other hand, he says the regenerative braking system works perfectly.

Advertising

The engine thus receives a rating of 15/20, the lowest score in its evaluation. It wasn't enough to spoil the experience, but it served as a reminder that the driving pleasure offered by hybrid technology could still be improved.

Chassis and Steering: Does the Tonale Retain Alfa Romeo's DNA?

It’s in terms of handling that the Tonale seems to have particularly won over its owner. After two decades behind the wheel of a Volkswagen Golf, Markus is discovering a different approach to driving. And he clearly likes it. «The front-end is precise,» he notes.

The steering is also one of the vehicle’s strengths, especially when Dynamic mode is activated. «In Dynamic mode, the steering is just right. » That’s an interesting compliment for a family SUV, whose primary purpose is to balance versatility and everyday comfort. On that last point, Markus is also satisfied. He describes the suspension as a «good compromise» and doesn’t mention any particular issues with the brakes.

In his view, the Tonale strikes a balance between comfort and sportiness. This results in an excellent rating of 18/20 for the chassis, steering, and overall handling.

Advertising

Life on board: impressive build quality and no electronic glitches

Build quality is often a sensitive issue when a driver accustomed to German brands decides to switch to an Italian car. With 20 years of experience at Volkswagen, Markus had a particularly interesting point of comparison.

After driving 10,000 kilometers in his Tonale, his assessment is positive. «No annoying background noise,» he says of the interior fit and finish. He remains cautious, however, about how the materials will hold up over time. «As for how they’ll age, I can’t say anything yet. The car is too new.»

In terms of ergonomics, the owner appreciates how the multimedia system works, which he finds smooth. No electronic glitches were reported during this period. But one detail in particular catches his attention: the climate control buttons. «Everything works smoothly. The climate control still has real physical buttons, which is a big plus.» At a time when many automakers are consolidating nearly all functions into touchscreens, Alfa Romeo’s ergonomic choice seems to be a hit.

When it comes to interior space and practicality, Markus also feels that the Tonale fully meets his needs. The overall assessment is therefore reassuring: no rattles in the cabin, no reported electronic malfunctions, and well-designed ergonomics. The car as a whole earns 17/20.

Advertising

Actual fuel consumption: 6.4 L/100 km on average

Beyond his impressions of the driving experience, Markus also shared his fuel economy figures. These are interesting numbers for drivers considering the purchase of a 160 ch Tonale Hybrid.

The consumption figures recorded by Markus

Driving ConditionsConsumption
City6.4 L/100 km
Highway at 130 km/h6.0 L/100 km
Overall Average6.4 L/100 km

These figures reflect the owner’s reported fuel consumption, not measurements taken by the editorial staff. Interestingly, Markus reports slightly lower fuel consumption on the highway at 130 km/h than in the city. This result serves as a reminder that a hybrid vehicle’s actual fuel consumption also depends on driving conditions. With an average of 6.4 l/100 km over his trip, the owner seems satisfied with the overall performance of his Italian SUV.

Advertising

A software recall, but no unpleasant surprises at the repair shop

As for reliability, there is one issue worth noting. The Tonale was subject to a recall involving the engine management software. Markus does not specify the details of the repair, but reports no additional breakdowns.

As for his experience with the Alfa Romeo dealership network, it’s been quite encouraging, especially when he compares it to his years with Volkswagen. «It’s cheaper than at Volkswagen. So far, I have no complaints. » However, he does not provide any specific figures that would allow for a comparison of maintenance costs between the two brands. After ten months, his experience with customer service has been positive, although it’s still too early to judge long-term reliability.

From Volkswagen to Alfa Romeo: Design and Emotion Make the Difference

This may be the most revealing part of Markus’s story. For 20 years, he chose Volkswagen Golfs—cars that were a part of his daily life across several generations. Yet all it took was the design of an Alfa Romeo Tonale to convince him to switch brands entirely.

And ten months later, the magic still seems to be working. When asked what sets his Tonale apart from his previous Volkswagens, Markus immediately points to the design. But beyond the aesthetics, he also believes that his Alfa Romeo has that extra bit of soul that enthusiasts readily associate with the Italian brand.

Advertising

When asked whether his Tonale evokes that special feeling in him, he answers without hesitation: «Absolutely.»

And to sum up that feeling in a single word, he chose an Italian term: «Emozione.»

A short answer, but one that probably explains better than any long speech why this German driver abandoned two decades of loyalty to Volkswagen. Markus gives this emotional aspect the highest rating: 20/20.

Verdict: An Alfa Romeo Tonale that won him over

After driving 10,000 kilometers, Markus gives his Alfa Romeo Tonale Hybrid 160 ch Intensa a very positive review. He still finds the Italian SUV just as appealing to the eye as he did on day one. He appreciates the precision of the front-wheel drive, the steering in Dynamic mode, the suspension setup, and the interior design. Fuel consumption remains moderate according to his records, and his experience with the Alfa Romeo dealership network has been satisfactory so far.

Advertising

Nevertheless, there are still a few concerns, particularly the jerks that occur when switching between the electric and internal combustion engines. A software recall campaign also marked this first year of use. But these imperfections do not seem to undermine his attachment to the car.

Ultimately, this testimonial illustrates what still sets Alfa Romeo apart: its ability to captivate drivers beyond mere rational considerations.

Markus didn’t just trade in his Volkswagen Golf for a hybrid SUV. He discovered a car that stirs emotions he still enjoys experiencing every day. And after 20 years of loyalty to a German brand, that may be the Tonale’s greatest achievement.

This review is based on the account of Markus, a German member of the Italpassion community. The opinions, fuel consumption figures, and ratings presented here reflect his personal experience after driving 10,000 kilometers, and do not represent a review conducted by the editorial staff. You can, too Post a review of your Italian car on Italpassion.

Advertising
Advertising

Actual fuel consumption

  • City : 6.4 L/100 km
  • Highway at 130 km/h : 6 L/100 km
  • Average : 6.4 L/100 km

Reliability and After-Sales Service

Problems Encountered : software recall campaign

Satisfaction SAV : Bonne

Summary Technical Data Sheet

  • Power : 160 ch
  • From 0 to 60 mph : 8.8 s
  • Conso mixte constructeur : 5.9 L/100 km
  • Prix neuf annoncé : 53000
  • Gearbox : Automatique
I fell head over heels in love with the Tonale's design at first sight. And I still am today.

Rating Details

  • Engine, Transmission, and Driving Experience 15 / 20
  • Chassis, Steering, and Handling 18 / 20
  • Life on Board and Finishes 17 / 20
  • Fuel Economy, Reliability, and After-Sales Service 17 / 20
  • The Italian Spirit and Competition 20 / 20

Overall Rating : 85.8 / 100


Like this post? Share it!

Leave a review